Today you will
- check one claim in three different places
- spot when pages just copy each other
- record your check in a file called {{code:sm4_independence_check}}
Warm-up
Three websites all say: "In Ireland, the digital age of consent is 16." What would convince you that they did not copy each other?
Independent sources reach the same claim using their own evidence, not each other's.
A copy cascade is one piece of text copied across several pages.
Circular citation is when two sources only point to each other as proof.
A cross-check means testing one claim in separate places to see if each source stands alone.
Example
An official page says the digital age of consent is 16. A news site rewrites that page, and a blog quotes the news. That is one source copied twice, not three checks.
As a class, sort six source cards into independent verification or not independent. Talk about each card first, then place it and check.
Ask yourself: could each source still stand if the other two vanished?
Independent or copied?
Common issues
- Three pages agree, so I thought they were independent. Check whether they all rewrite the same press release or article.
- I can't tell if two news sites copied each other. If the wording matches closely, count them as one source.
- My third source is a post sharing the first article. A share isn't a new source. Find a page with its own evidence.
Independent Practice
- Go to {{code:onedrive.com}} or {{code:drive.google.com}}, open {{code:Project_Portfolio}}, then open {{code:09_specialism/sm4/}}.
- Make a new document in that folder called {{code:sm4_independence_check}}.
- Pick one factual claim from your {{code:sm4_search_log}}. If it is empty, use the class claim in the box.
- Copy the layout in the box into your document.
- Find the claim in three sources, fill in each row and write your verdict.
If all three turn out to be copies, say so in your verdict. That still counts.
- My file is saved in {{code:09_specialism/sm4/}}.
- My claim is one clear sentence.
- Each of my three sources has a title, a link and an independence note.
- I wrote a verdict at the end.
Class claim: In Ireland, the digital age of consent is 16.
Claim (one sentence): ________________________________
| Source | Title | URL | What it says about the claim | Independence note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (sample) | Citizens Information guidance | https://www.citizensinformation.ie (find the digital age of consent page) | States the digital age of consent in Ireland is 16 | Independent, official original page |
| 2 | independent / depends on… / copy of… | |||
| 3 | independent / depends on… / copy of… |
Overall verdict: independent verification / partial dependence / copy cascade (and what you will do next if needed)
Unlock the full learning experience
You're previewing this lesson. Get full access to this lesson and hundreds more — each one ready to teach, with interactive activities, printable resources and pupil progress tracking built in.
This lesson is copyright of Coding Ireland 2017 - 2026. Unauthorised use, copying or distribution is not allowed.